Round And Round Goes The Business Roundtable

Henry Mintzberg
Written by Henry Mintzberg December 14, 2019

Recently, with much fanfare, the Business Roundtable—the association of CEOs of major American companies—discovered stakeholders beyond shareholders. Or, at least, rediscovered them, again. For this roundtable, what goes around really does come around. Here is an excerpt from each of its four proclamations over the years. Together, they are telling.

948 1140x0

This year, The Purpose of a Corporation avowed that “While each of our individual companies serves its own corporate purpose, we share a fundamental commitment to all of our stakeholders.”

In 2012, the Principles of Corporate Governance avowed that “it is the responsibility of the corporation to deal with its employees, customers, suppliers, and other constituencies in a fair and equitable manner…”

In contrast, the 1997 Statement of Corporate Governance declared: “The notion that the board must somehow balance the interests of stockholders against the interests of other stakeholders fundamentally misconstrues the role of directors. It is, moreover, an unworkable notion because it would leave the board with no criterion for resolving conflicts between interests of stockholders and of other stakeholders or among different groups of stakeholders.”

Coming back around to 1981, the Statement on Corporate Responsibility avowed that “Balancing the shareholder’s expectations of maximum return against other priorities is one of the fundamental problems confronting corporate management. …giving enlightened consideration to balancing the legitimate claims of all its constituents, a corporation will best serve the interest of the shareholders.”

If the CEOs were right in 1981, why did they go wrong in 1997? And if they reversed that wrong in 2012, why do they have to repeat that reversal now? The abuses of Shareholder Value did not exactly diminish in the last seven years, so why should we take the latest proclamation any more seriously?

Most telling is the claim in 1997 about having no criterion for resolving conflicts among different stakeholders. How about judgment? Did the CEOs of America lose their judgment in 1997? Jack Welch apparently did. I have been told that this renowned CEO of GE—no longer quite so renowned with his company’s subsequent performance—championed that 1997 statement. Then in 2009, he came around, declaring Shareholder Value to be the “the dumbest idea in the world.” Whoops, looks like he made a little mistake in 1997. Sorry about that!

Will the CEOs of America regain that judgment now, so that their stakeholders will get a fair shake this time around? We had the words in 2012; will we get the actions now?

Here’s an idea for action: Reserve half the seats on the board of American corporations for elected representatives of the workers. No, I have not lost my mind. I am simply stating what Germany did in 1976: By law, employee representatives have been filing 10 of the 20 board memberships in companies of more than 2000 people. The German economy has hardly been suffering ever since.

Here’s an idea for action: Reserve half the seats on the board of American corporations for elected representatives of the workers.
Click to tweet

If the CEOs of corporate America don’t like this idea, here’s another: Get rid of executive compensation schemes and quarterly reports that drive their attention toward short-run gains in the stock price, so often at the expense of worker security. And another: Stop lobbying for tax changes that favor corporate shareholders over other people in society. And, while you are at it, support a living minimum wage for workers. How about ending the lobbying that has being doing so much damage to American democracy? The possibilities are endless…for leaders who deserve that label.

These days, words go round and round while behaviors carry on. Being bombarded with proclamations and so much else, we lose memory, alongside judgment. The CEOs of corporate America now have the opportunity to come around finally: put their actions where their mouthpiece is.

950 1140x0

This is a guest blog by Henry Mintzberg. It was orginially posted here.

Written by Henry Mintzberg
Henry Mintzberg
I am a writer and educator, mostly about managing originations, developing managers, and rebalancing societies, also an outdoorsman and collector of beaver sculptures. I'm co-founder of CoachingOurselves.com & IMPM.org
Share or join the discussion!
Our newsletter
Are you ready for more revolutionary content?
Join 50.000+ subscribers reinventing the way the world works
Read more
Jan 28, 2023
Mayden’s No Blame Culture
Michele Rees-Jones Written by Michele Rees-Jones
‘Blame’ is a loaded, negative word. But it’s a common reaction when something goes wrong. Some even look for people to blame. It shifts…
Read more
Sep 21, 2022
Why You Should Separate Salary And Performance
Marc-Peter Pijper Written by Marc-Peter Pijper
We all believe a great school report deserves a tenner, right? Well, I disagree. Here's why I believe that. And how that translates to…
Read more
Jul 16, 2022
We've Got Blood On Our Clothes
Pim de Morree Written by Pim de Morree
How many people do you think work in the global garment industry? And how many of those are women? The answer: 40 million (!) workers, of…
Read more
Jun 25, 2022
Coaching For Everyone? It Really Can Be Done!
Michele Rees-Jones Written by Michele Rees-Jones
How many times have you heard of companies coaching candidates for ‘senior teams’, ‘top talent’ and ‘future leaders? That is, the ‘special…
Read more
Jun 11, 2022
Introducing... Our Newest Endeavor(!)
Pim de Morree Written by Pim de Morree
Today is an important day in Corporate Rebels history! We are announcing a new product we believe has the potential to radically change the…
Read more
May 21, 2022
A World Cup Built Off The Back Of Modern Slavery
Emma de Blok Written by Emma de Blok
The 2022 FIFA World Cup has been appearing in the news for all the wrong reasons and is already one of the most controversial sporting…
Read more
Read all articles