Time To Experiment: Democratizing Our Budgets

Bram van der Lecq
Written by Bram van der Lecq May 06, 2020

Besides from being part of Corporate Rebels, I'm a governance researcher for a startup called Polis. We are developing methods and mechanisms that help other purpose driven organizations be more democratic. This way not only shareholders, but all stakeholders can have influence on the decisions that are made. We want to practice what we preach. So that’s why we started an experiment to see how we could democratize our budgets.

1182 1140x0

Some context

When we started this experiment we didn’t have any team-budgets. The only source of income we have were the funds provided by the founder of the company, while all our teams are currently in research stage. This meant that we could focus all our time on research and steadily grow our organization, while we weren't making any profit. Nevertheless, at the end of the month everyone would receive their salary on their bank-account. No questions asked.

This might seem a bit strange for a company in the startup stage, but compared to a lot of traditional organizations I think it's not that different. Everybody is working really hard and is focused on their tasks, but most of us don't know how their efforts are influencing the results of the company, or where the money that ends up in their bank-accounts comes from.

Access wasn't enough

Unlike traditional organizations, at Polis, everyone has access to all (financial) information. Every member can see the salaries of their colleagues and we receive regular updates on how much money we spent as an organization.

Even though we had access to all of this, nobody seemed to really care or understand much about finances. Rather logical. We all got our salary at the end of the month, and funds didn't seem to be running out anytime soon, so why bother? Does this sound familiar for those of you working in more traditional organizations?

Why we bothered

We are a purpose driven company, so we're not interested in making as much money as we can. For us talking about money isn’t about optimizing our profits, it is about choosing how to invest and set priorities. We believe that we can make better decisions by enabling the wisdom of the whole organization. Furthermore we wish to encourage all our members to be interested in how we spent money and participate in deciding what our priorities are.

Keeping this in mind we formulated the goals for a successful experiment;

  • We want a solution that would increase the sense of ownership amongst our members
  • We want to create more awareness that funds can run out and we need to keep that in mind when setting priorities.
  • We want to provide more insight on a team-level so that everyone can understand how the finances of their team work, and have the skills to influence it.
  • By creating team-budgets we want to empower teams to make their own decisions regarding hiring and team expenses.
We believe that we can make better decisions by enabling the wisdom of the whole organization.
Click to tweet

The experiment

After identifying what we wanted to do, we created the following experiment:

We divided the budget into team budgets, broke that down into monthly budgets based on the expense of previous months (salary, tools, etc.) and shared that with the teams.

  • This made it easier for each team to see how much they spend on what and where they could save money.
  • The teams use the monthly budgets as a guideline, they are free to spend more money. But they are aware of the consequences, because spending more will bring down the runway of their team.

If at the end of the period a team has spend less then their budget, they can redistribute the remaining monthly budget in three ways;

  • They can decide to add the funds to their own team’s budget and increase their runway, or save money for some investments in the future.
  • They can redistribute their funds to any of the other teams if they think it makes more sense for that team to use the funds.
  • They can choose to redistribute their funds to a Collaborative Fund, for which any member of the organization can create proposals.

By default, any remaining funds will be added to the Collaborative Fund. So if a team wants to redistribute their funds differently, they have to state that.

The Collaborative Fund (inspired by Enspiral’s Co-budget) can be used to finance proposals created by any of the members.

  • Any member can create a proposal for how to spend the money in the Collaborative Fund. Using our Proposal & Decision making process the organization can decide how we spend that fund.

The funds members loan to the organization are added to your team's budget.

  • Inspired by Italian worker-cooperatives, every member has the possibility to loan part of their salary back to the organization. Employees get higher returns then they would on the bank, and the company has a cheaper loan.
  • The funds you loan to the organization will be added to the teams budget, giving you the chance to influence how the money is used.

Rules to guide the experiment

The teams are free to decide how they spend their money. If they want to hire someone, they can! However, they also know that they are affected by the consequences and the salaries need to come out of their budget.

By default any remaining funds are added to the Collaborative Fund. This might seem harsh and unfair but we think that, especially in the beginning, there has to be some incentive for everyone to think about it and make a conscious decision.

The teams are free to decide how to come to a decision. They can choose a finance representative, collaboratively decide each month, or come up with their own alternative.

We will evaluate the experiment after a couple of months and if there are any concerns in the meantime those can and should be shared in our assembly or via Slack.


What we hope this experiment will do;

  • It forces teams to think about why and how to distribute funds.

If your team thinks it's important we do more marketing, it's probably not a smart thing to redistribute your funds to the Governance Team.

  • It aims to stimulate information sharing and collaboration between teams

If you don’t know what other teams are working on, you’ll probably not give them any of the remaining budgets.

  • Teams pitching ideas/proposals to the rest of the organization to get additional funding.
  • We hope that this will be a first step in getting more financial awareness and ownership within our organization, and we are convinced that we’ve learned a lot once we evaluate after a couple of months.

Potential negative outcomes;

We thought about this and identified some potential negative outcomes that we wanted to prevent while designing this experiment.

  • Teams start spending more money to make sure they spend everything in their budget (hopefully the option to any remaining funds to your own team’s budget prevents this behavior)
  • Teams getting into disputes over money (luckily we have some conflict resolutions methods that will help us if this becomes reality)
  • Teams not making conscious decisions about how to redistribute their funds, but just keep adding their funds to their own team-accounts as a ritual. (We hope that transparency counters this)
  • And probably many other negative outcomes we couldn't think of yet, but that we hope to prevent with a thorough evaluation

What we learned thus far

After presenting these ideas, discussing the concerns, adding and changing some of the elements, we voted on the proposal and it was accepted. The experiment has just started and it's too fresh to draw any conclusions, but there are some things we learned when preparing it. Giving access to (financial) information is not enough, you need to present in a way that people understand. Making everyone responsible motivates them to not waste money. One of the teams quickly realized they were still paying for a tool they weren't using anymore. Canceling it immediately increased their runway. Simple as that. And last but not least, discussing and trying to understand issues raised by the other members, helped us improve the experiment by adding the Collaborative Fund.

I'm pretty sure that in a couple of months, we have much more lessons. To be continued...

Written by Bram van der Lecq
Bram van der Lecq
Read more
Jun 30, 2024
Budgetless Companies: The Case of Mainfreight
Joost Minnaar Written by Joost Minnaar
Mainfreight, a global logistics powerhouse headquartered in Auckland, New Zealand, has been redefining business success since its inception…
Read more about Budgetless Companies: The Case of Mainfreight
Apr 28, 2021
Bottom-Up Funding: A New Approach To Innovation
HappyHenry Written by HappyHenry
GCHQ is the UK government’s intelligence service, based in Cheltenham in the West of England. Though in some ways a traditional…
Read more about Bottom-Up Funding: A New Approach To Innovation
Jul 04, 2020
For Annual Planning, Investing Beats Budgeting
Rob Solomon Written by Rob Solomon
By using principles from venture investing, companies can make smarter resource allocation decisions and help their departments become more…
Read more about For Annual Planning, Investing Beats Budgeting
Dec 26, 2018
Why We Should Change The Rhythm Of Business
Bjarte Bogsnes Written by Bjarte Bogsnes
There once was a Finance manager who met a fisherman. “Could you please tell me about your life and your work?”, asks the Finance manager.…
Read more about Why We Should Change The Rhythm Of Business
Oct 27, 2018
The Cat And Dog Relationship Between HR And Finance
Bjarte Bogsnes Written by Bjarte Bogsnes
I belong to the rather small group of finance people who also have worked in HR. The four years I headed up HR in the petrochemicals…
Read more about The Cat And Dog Relationship Between HR And Finance
Aug 15, 2018
How These 3 Companies Manage Cost Without A Traditional Budget
Bjarte Bogsnes Written by Bjarte Bogsnes
Although Beyond Budgeting is about so much more than just budgets, our name tends to draw people, at least initially, towards the budget…
Read more about How These 3 Companies Manage Cost Without A Traditional Budget
Read all articles

Download: Free Guide

Unlock our in-depth guide on trends, tools, and best practices from over 150 pioneering organizations.

Subscribe below and receive it directly in your inbox.

    We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.