The 1 Thing That Immediately Kills Your Company

Joost Minnaar
Written by Joost Minnaar November 08, 2018

“Bureaucracy must die!” shouted Gary Hamel from the stage of the 2nd RenDanHeYi Forum in China recently. This influential guru is on a mission to rid organizations of bureaucracy.

536 1140x0

As Corporate Rebels, we strongly support his campaign. It is urgently needed. Why? Because bureaucracy in large organizations is growing, not shrinking. This, despite all the recent talk about fads like 'Teal'and ‘Holacracy’.

Gary and his co-worker Michele Zanini have shown that most large organizations have 8 or more layers of management. That’s 8 or more! What the hell are they all for?

The $9 Trillion bureaucracy trap

Hamel’s data shows that large companies have become even more conservative, more rule-bound and more centralized. This is untenable. It’s a waste of resources, and just plain bullshit. For too long now we have built organizations on toxic processes that add no real value to society—but cost heaps.

And this isn’t just small change. It costs us a crazy amount of money! According to Hamel & Zanini excess bureaucracy costs the US, alone, $3 trillion per year. They recently estimated the figure to be around $9 trillion for the OECD countries. That’s a 9 with 12 zero’s!

Cost Of Bureaucracy

Removing the 'uninstallable'

These insights confirm that most of us endure useless bureaucracy on a daily basis. In some way, it infects the organizations we all work in or depend on. Despite these enormous costs, it’s still the default operating system for large organizations. And it is still regarded widely as basic, simple and scalable.

According to research excess bureaucracy costs the US, alone, $3 trillion per year. They recently estimated the figure to be around $9 trillion for the OECD countries. That’s a 9 with 12 zero’s!
Click to tweet

But this is not true now, if it ever was. Today, bureaucracy looms as a dangerous liability. As Gary puts it: “The world is becoming more turbulent faster than organisations are becoming more resilient.”

From bureaucracy to humanocracy

But the uninstall button is hard to find. There is no simple process to remove bureaucracy. Indeed, Gary advocates a gradual transition from bureaucracy to what he calls ‘humanocracy’. The concept of humanocracy is based on the best practices of progressive workplaces we are more than familiar with.

Among these are Bucket List organizations like Haier, Morning Star, Handelsbanken, W.L. Gore and Spotify They have all proven capable of running large and complex organizations with lean management practices and a minimum of bureaucracy.

10 pointers of humanocracy

Some have decades of experience, which gives them significant business advantage. They show the rest of us how to ditch excess bureaucracy. They inspire Gary’s 10 distinguishing characteristics of humanocracies:

  • Everyone acts like an owner
  • Operating units are small (less than 50 individuals)
  • Leaders are chosen by the led
  • There are no internal monopolies
  • Control comes from 'around' not 'above'
  • Tasks are chosen, not assigned
  • Coordination is the product of collaboration
  • Decisions reflect the wisdom of the crowd
  • Organizational boundaries are seamless
  • Everyone reports to the customer

Rolling out change is bullshit

We are pleased to see these 10 characteristics align well with our 8 habits of highly progressive workplaces. Organizations can draw inspiration from this cluster of principles and processes. Those that do will enjoy the advantages of scale without falling into the trap of building inherently toxic structures.

But how can traditional organizations reinvent themselves? How can they transform towards a humanocracy? How can they effectively end bureaucracy? These million dollar questions beg answers.

Gary doesn’t advocate a ‘big-bang’ approach—that is, layering on a new model with a set of pre-fixed practices. There is no single model or solution. The idea of a fixed solution is bullshit. Worse, it is more likely to provoke backslash than progress.

An enormous variation of best-practices

Most progressive organization do not share a specific set of best practices. They vary widely. This is the most important argument against starting change with a fixed solution.

“It is not about the particular practices, but rather about the principles on which they are based.” Practices will vary over time. Instead, start your transformation with a defining a set of principles. Practices will emerge, and they might be inspired by other progressive workplaces.

Revolution & Evolution

Gary believes transformations emerge from continuing experiments. “Experiments that should be revolutionary in intent, but evolutionary in practice.” Instead of implementing a fixed model, create and sustain a process of ‘discovery’.

Organizational change: experiments should be revolutionary in intent, but evolutionary in practice.
Click to tweet

Organizations can support this by encouraging people to select their own experiments, in a crowd-sourcing way. They should have the freedom to try out new ideas. That gives them a real voice in developing their ‘organization of the future’.

Only then bureaucracy might end.

Written by Joost Minnaar
Joost Minnaar
Co-founder Corporate Rebels. My daily focus is on research, writing, and anything else related to making work more fun.
Read more
Nov 19, 2023
Ethical AI and Self-Organization: Charting a Path Forward
Joost Schouten Written by Joost Schouten
AI at scale in our society scares me. With wealth inequality perpetually growing, anger in public discourse on the rise, and little…
Read more about Ethical AI and Self-Organization: Charting a Path Forward
Oct 15, 2023
The Power of Good Jobs and Progressive Management
Joost Minnaar Written by Joost Minnaar
In August, we traveled to Hanoi for Bucket list visits to a group of progressive Vietnamese businesses that challenge the status quo. On…
Read more about The Power of Good Jobs and Progressive Management
Oct 01, 2023
Rethinking Workplace Transformation: The Art of Subtraction
Joost Minnaar Written by Joost Minnaar
Why you should always ask employees to delete things, not to add things.  During workshops with our clients, we often do this simple…
Read more about Rethinking Workplace Transformation: The Art of Subtraction
Sep 24, 2023
Shattering the Illusion of Uniqueness Bias in Leadership
Joost Minnaar Written by Joost Minnaar
“We are too small.” “We are too big.” “We are in retail.” “We are in health care.” “We are a non-profit.” “We are in highly regulated…
Read more about Shattering the Illusion of Uniqueness Bias in Leadership
Nov 09, 2022
What If Your Company Was Divided Up Into Countless Startups?
Joost Minnaar Written by Joost Minnaar
From a juggernaut with 80,000 employees to thousands of small companies with ten to fifteen employees. Haier, the renown Chinese…
Read more about What If Your Company Was Divided Up Into Countless Startups?
Oct 15, 2022
The Great Resignation. Quiet Quitting. What The F***?
Pim de Morree Written by Pim de Morree
The Great Resignation was all the hype earlier this year. Then Quiet Quitting took over the headlines when hordes of people popularized…
Read more about The Great Resignation. Quiet Quitting. What The F***?
Read all articles

Download: Free Guide

Unlock our in-depth guide on trends, tools, and best practices from over 150 pioneering organizations.

Subscribe below and receive it directly in your inbox.

    We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.